I've had time to contemplate this one. Saw it on a night off from painting. (Venue: the Grand Illusion). Dan and I had the theater to ourselves, which was perfect because this is one that begs throwing out comments and asking questions in real time. When the movie begins, you learn a few things about the intriguing Yella: she has a stalker, she's accepted a job away from the home she shares with her dad in Eastern Germany and she takes a loan from her dad (which turns out to be his nest egg). These details set the stage for the fiasco that follows.
(Spoiler Alert: Read at Your Own Risk!)
Yella and her father portray a peculiar, almost sexual relationship. You only get a brief scene but the feeling lingers. The stalker turns out to be her estranged husband who is still hurting from her departure. While Yella makes terrible (almost unbelievable) decisions, I was entirely edge-of-my-seating it. I was rumbling to Dan: "She's nuts, why would she do that, NO WAY!" Dan had his own rumblings, but we were sucked in. The worse her decisions (accepting a ride from her stalker, taking a job offer from a shady business owner, trusting a different shady stranger defrauding people out of money, choosing to become the business partner of the second shyster and then falling for him), the more she tricked me into wanting to know more. What is at Yella's motivational core? Wait for it...can you guess...MONEY! That's the other part of this movie...it's brutally honest. Her decisions are money-based. (Yella, herself, wouldn't disagree.) People's relationships to money are as diverse as people themselves and this twists up this story.
The story sequence is in flashbacks and what seems like real-time. You spend a lot of time with Yella. Maybe that's why you feel like Christian Petzold has taken you on an enjoyable ride and then after a snap, he yanks you off, making you feel short-changed. Initially, I HATED the ending; seemed like a cheap way out. After discussing it more with Dan over Korean-style spicy squid, I came to dislike it less. Best to leave it there. The details are rich if you choose to pay attention to them, the clarity forms.
Themes: trust, economic issues, unhappy marriage, East Germany
Director: Christian Petzold
Country: Germany
Genre: Thriller/Drama
Minutes: 89
Scale: 3
Pay attention or perhaps watch it twice, but this is a must-see. Upon second viewing, so much more makes sense initially because you know each character's intentions from the get-go. It's an exciting and fast-moving plot and the way the pieces add up at the end, it sparkles. The casting is a show-business trifecta: Tilda Swinton opposite George Clooney opposite Tom Wilkinson.
This movie, as in many of Bier's films, depicts how pain and sadness seek out hope in surprising places. I'm partial to Bier's movies: After the Wedding ( 2006), Brothers (2004) and Open Hearts (2002) made me cry. They have the same formula--a woman suddenly left without her boyfriend or husband due to some traumatic event. A different man enters the scene to help out and it's what follows. Sounds basic, sappy and a little sexist but the stories are always complicatedly woven to keep your interest. The plot subtly provides essential details without distracting you. I wanted to understand what drove Jerry to become an addict, after it was mentioned he'd been a lawyer. He names the drugs he started with--just one sentence about why and it's enough. The actors are brilliant portraying their characters' raw emotion. You connect with the characters on a non-verbal level, making some explanations irrelevant.
Upon weekend's end when they call regarding the dead girl, the questions begin. When did you find her? Why didn't you report it immediately? This makes the town news and unleashes racial tension as the dead girl is aborigine and the men are white. Claire is incensed with Stewart and becomes obsessed with the case.
You become acquainted with the recurring characters; this helps strings the seasons and plots.


